On the Ground in Virginia's Data Center Boom: An Interview with Ashish Kapoor of the Piedmont Environmental Council
Ashish Kapoor is a Senior Energy and Climate Advisor at the Piedmont Environmental Council (PEC), a Virginia land conservation and advocacy nonprofit. His work focuses on enabling distributed energy resources (DERs) and agrivoltaics as data center demand drives unprecedented load growth in Virginia.
He is the project lead on the first crop-based agrivoltaics project in Virginia, where PEC worked with agricultural leader and farmer Teddy Pitsiokos to combine crops, solar and storage on the same site and run it like an experiment.
In this interview, Kapoor provides insight into DERs’ scale potential in Virginia, how to ground climate policy in human relationships and trust in order to produce durable change, and the exciting state-level policy that makes Virginia a top locus of energy innovation in the United States today.
At this year’s Yale Clean Energy Conference, Kapoor will co-lead a workshop with Louise White of the Commonwealth of Virginia on the Data Center and Renewables Nexus.
Can you paint a brief picture of demand growth in Virginia, and how the various parties are reacting to it?
Prior to this expansion of the data centers, we were basically in a flat growth environment. Now, there’s anticipated to be a doubling or even a tripling of peak load demand. It took a long time to build out this much of the grid, 100+ years. So, we're in a very compressed timeline.
All of that electric infrastructure, generation and transmission, is rate-based. It's paid for by the ratepayer. The investor-owned utilities are getting a guaranteed rate of return of just a shade under 10% on whatever they invest. So they are incentivized to build out more of the required capacity, but that leaves the burden on the ratepayers of Virginia to fund the build-out, when alternatives exist.
Being in an 60- to 70-gigawatt peak load environment (as opposed to 24 or 25 today) is reshaping conversations about all technologies and energy solutions, including solar and distributed resources.
DERs and agrivoltaics are often treated as tools around the margin. Do you disagree? How do you characterize their potential?
We’re in an environment now where DERs and agrivoltaics are no longer tools at the margin. We often hear that “rooftop solar isn't going to get us out of this,” right? But it can do a tremendous amount when we think about it as DERs, pair it with storage and frame it as all these different pieces of a puzzle. We’ve seen so much potential here. PEC helped develop SB234, a parking lot solar development program, and the Virginia Farm Bureau, Cattlemen’s Association and agribusiness all organically came out to support it.
That showed me that people want to be for things, but you have to give them the toolbox to do it. There's nothing inherently political about a solar panel, but it's been framed that way.
Is DER potential in Virginia at the gigawatt scale? What have you modeled?
Yes, it is. The Virginia Energy Plan released by Governor Spanberger sketches out 10 gigawatts of DER goals by 2045. We think it can be even more than that. In addition to my work at PEC, I’m appointed to a statewide DER Task Force, which is presenting recommendations in November. We’re working on a final projection number, but we see between 10 and 20 gigawatts of DER capacity.
That sounds like a lot, but other states and new technologies are paving the way for this scale: New York has added 7 or 8 gigawatts of DERs; and batteries and virtual power plants (VPPs) mean we can effectively aggregate them now. That secret battery sauce has raised the ceiling.
How can DERs provide citizens a sense of ownership in the climate fight without creating inequitable outcomes?
Take Solar for All: Virginia was awarded around $160 million under the Inflation Reduction Act for solar deployments in low-income communities, though that funding is now tied up in litigation after EPA moved to terminate the program. These grants really matter, but deploying projects appropriately is at least equally important. When the government, developers or installers do wrong, word really gets around and can be fuel for disinformation as well as general mistrust of the technology.
So when we’re talking about solar on a farm, we need to frame it around energy independence and protecting our farmers, not carbon. When we do that, we’ve seen really impressive results: there is a large group of stakeholders now asking why we’re paying more for our electricity, who’s making money off of it and what can we do about it. That community is sending in written comments in favor of net metering, and forming coalitions to exercise their rights together. PEC worked with Dunsky to produce a value-of-solar study that helped form the basis for more than 1,300 written comments on Dominion Energy’s petition to the Virginia State Corporation Commission to cut net metering. PEC intervened alongside Solar United Neighbors, Vote Solar and the Sierra Club, and we won. This led to a rejection of Dominion’s proposal to cut their net metering program.
PEC is embedded in our community for the long haul, and that gives us more trust. We’re not here just focused on climate—we’re really focused on all the issues that are rooted here, from historic preservation to transmission and land use.
PEC has endorsed a pause on new data center siting while you push to mobilize distributed capacity quickly. Are those in tension?
Frankly, the radical middle is messy, right? There's not necessarily a clear line. Ultimately, we believe that a pause like many other states have taken is warranted in order to reevaluate what we've wrought upon not just ourselves, but upon the entire PJM grid.
When you get out of the energy wonk bubble, data centers are kind of an 80/20 issue. For us, it’s not new: PEC was talking about this for five years, and it seemed like nobody cares, nobody cares, nobody cares… Now it's swung.
For now, we think pausing data center siting, expanding DERs and seeing where the dust settles with load growth gives us the best hedge against stranded assets, against paying for gas plants and transmission lines we don’t need for the next 30 years.
It also gives us a faster path. We need a lot of electrons, and DERs are really the fastest way to connect clean energy, or any energy, to the grid. We’ve seen international examples where distributed solar has really rushed in and reshaped the grid. In Pakistan, there were a huge number of stranded gas plants, bills ballooned, then tens of GW of rooftop solar in a short period. Australia too. And beyond the energy they provide, plug-in/balcony solar builds a positive relationship with solar energy that can have a political impact outside of the grid.
In Virginia and at PEC, we really focus on listening to the real concerns that citizens have rather than dismissing them outright or pretending there aren’t trade-offs. For instance, we’ve heard concern that PFAS and heavy metals coming off solar panels are a soil concern. We take that seriously and we now work with Virginia Tech to test soil under our agrivoltaics site every year and share our results. Rather than dismissing concerns, we want to build engagement and trust by sharing real risks and what we can do to mitigate them.
What are you most excited about in Virginia right now?
In Virginia, we have a governor who is very engaged on energy and distributed energy in particular. The Distributed Generation Expansion Act quintuples the amount of distributed generation that Dominion has to build, including a gigawatt of distributed generation on previously disturbed sites. That's a nuclear power plant's worth of capacity being built on parking lots and brownfields. Thanks to other legislation signed into law this year, Virginia now has one of the most ambitious battery storage goals in the country - with a critical non–prescriptive model ordinance that can better help localities get the best siting and development standards implemented.
As a part of our DER Task Force recommendations, we have interconnection standards, robust plans for VPPs, technical assistance, and aggregating batteries into wholesale markets. That’s all very exciting for someone who’s been working in this space for a long time.
Finally, tell us about your workshop at the Yale Clean Energy Conference. What are you excited for?
I’m excited to be participating in the conference. I’ve worked with Louise White through the DER Task Force and I know we may have a technology player joining as well. I’m always eager to join these conversations, because there are a lot of interesting synergies at the intersection of facilitating virtual power plants at scale and remaining connected to what’s happening on the ground. We can’t lose sight of the fact that a lot of this is one meeting, one conversation at a time. Wholesale policy doesn't solve everything.
This interview has been edited for length and clarity.